{ "version": "0.3.0-draft", "current_question": "Q012", "questions": [ { "id": "Q001", "status": "accepted", "title": "主体と役割を分ける", "question": "法人・組織と役割を分離し、役割の割当に有効期間・対象範囲を持たせてよいか。", "rationale": "兼業、役割変更、地域差を表現し、法人名から事業資格や市場参加資格を自動推定しないため。", "answer": "法人と小売・発電等の役割を分離し、期間と対象範囲を持つ役割割当として記録する。同一法人の役割の追加・終了や、会社分割による別法人への役割の移転を表現できる構造とする。", "source_ids": [ "org", "chuden-split", "erex-generation" ], "affected_concepts": [ "Organization", "BusinessRole", "RoleAssignment", "Scope", "Period" ], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "Organization", "BusinessRole", "RoleAssignment", "Scope", "Period" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "RoleAssignment.organization", "RoleAssignment.role", "RoleAssignment.period", "RoleAssignment.scope" ], "added_concepts": [], "added_relationships": [], "deferred": [ "設備の停止・廃止・除却と役割終了の関係（Q002）", "有効期間の境界・不明値の正式な扱い", "役割変更の原因となる出来事の型" ] }, "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "affected_relationships": [ "RoleAssignment.organization", "RoleAssignment.role", "RoleAssignment.period", "RoleAssignment.scope" ], "notes": [ "設備の除却という論点を受領。具体企業・対象設備・実施日は未特定のため、実際の除却事実は未検証。", "今回の合意は主体・役割・期間・範囲の分離。期間端点の規約、全属性、行動ルールまで合意済みとは扱わない。" ] }, { "id": "Q002", "status": "accepted", "title": "設備の変化と役割の終了", "question": "設備の状態変化と役割終了を別記録にするか。", "rationale": "第2回の10問一括対話で確認。", "answer": "設備の変化と法人の役割終了は別に記録する。全ての保有発電設備が廃止・除却された場合は、それらに基づく発電者の役割が終わるという考え方を採用する。", "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "source_ids": [ "hokuden-retirement-plan", "generation-definition" ], "affected_concepts": [ "AssetEvent" ], "affected_relationships": [ "AssetEvent.id", "AssetEvent.label", "AssetEvent.kind", "AssetEvent.stage", "AssetEvent.actual_date", "AssetEvent.planned_date", "AssetEvent.evidence", "AssetEvent.asset" ], "affected_rules": [ "R004" ], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "AssetEvent" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "AssetEvent.id", "AssetEvent.label", "AssetEvent.kind", "AssetEvent.stage", "AssetEvent.actual_date", "AssetEvent.planned_date", "AssetEvent.evidence", "AssetEvent.asset" ], "accepted_rules": [ "R004" ], "added_concepts": [ "AssetEvent" ], "added_relationships": [ "AssetEvent.id", "AssetEvent.label", "AssetEvent.kind", "AssetEvent.stage", "AssetEvent.actual_date", "AssetEvent.planned_date", "AssetEvent.evidence", "AssetEvent.asset" ], "deferred": [ "設備の全件把握、実施済み、時点・範囲を確認する。保有外設備への運転・事業責任の関与が不明なら法人全体の役割終了は仮定つき示唆に留める。法的届出の廃止を自動生成しない。" ] }, "notes": [ "設備の全件把握、実施済み、時点・範囲を確認する。保有外設備への運転・事業責任の関与が不明なら法人全体の役割終了は仮定つき示唆に留める。法的届出の廃止を自動生成しない。" ], "resolution_kind": "conditional" }, { "id": "Q003", "status": "accepted", "title": "法人・グループ・連結範囲", "question": "法人、企業グループ、連結範囲と法人間関係を分けるか。", "rationale": "第2回の10問一括対話で確認。", "answer": "法人ごとの役割を分け、法人間関係、企業グループへの所属、財務集計範囲を別の関係として記録する。", "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "source_ids": [ "org", "chuden-split" ], "affected_concepts": [ "FinancialBoundary", "CorporateGroup", "GroupMembership", "OrganizationRelation" ], "affected_relationships": [ "CorporateGroup.id", "CorporateGroup.label", "GroupMembership.id", "GroupMembership.label", "OrganizationRelation.id", "OrganizationRelation.label", "GroupMembership.group", "GroupMembership.organization", "GroupMembership.period", "GroupMembership.evidence", "OrganizationRelation.source_organization", "OrganizationRelation.target_organization", "OrganizationRelation.kind", "OrganizationRelation.period", "OrganizationRelation.evidence", "FinancialBoundary.organization", "FinancialBoundary.period" ], "affected_rules": [], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "FinancialBoundary", "CorporateGroup", "GroupMembership", "OrganizationRelation" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "CorporateGroup.id", "CorporateGroup.label", "GroupMembership.id", "GroupMembership.label", "OrganizationRelation.id", "OrganizationRelation.label", "GroupMembership.group", "GroupMembership.organization", "GroupMembership.period", "GroupMembership.evidence", "OrganizationRelation.source_organization", "OrganizationRelation.target_organization", "OrganizationRelation.kind", "OrganizationRelation.period", "OrganizationRelation.evidence", "FinancialBoundary.organization", "FinancialBoundary.period" ], "accepted_rules": [], "added_concepts": [ "CorporateGroup", "GroupMembership", "OrganizationRelation" ], "added_relationships": [ "CorporateGroup.id", "CorporateGroup.label", "GroupMembership.id", "GroupMembership.label", "OrganizationRelation.id", "OrganizationRelation.label", "GroupMembership.group", "GroupMembership.organization", "GroupMembership.period", "GroupMembership.evidence", "OrganizationRelation.source_organization", "OrganizationRelation.target_organization", "OrganizationRelation.kind", "OrganizationRelation.period", "OrganizationRelation.evidence", "FinancialBoundary.organization", "FinancialBoundary.period" ], "deferred": [] }, "notes": [], "resolution_kind": "adopted" }, { "id": "Q004", "status": "accepted", "title": "所有・運転保守・事業責任", "question": "設備への関与を所有、運転保守、事業責任に分けるか。", "rationale": "第2回の10問一括対話で確認。", "answer": "設備を所有する主体、運転保守を担う主体、事業責任を負う主体を別々の関係として記録する。同じ法人が複数を担う場合も表現する。", "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "source_ids": [ "org", "generation-definition" ], "affected_concepts": [ "Asset", "AssetOwnership", "AssetOperation", "AssetResponsibility" ], "affected_relationships": [ "AssetOwnership.id", "AssetOwnership.label", "AssetOperation.id", "AssetOperation.label", "AssetResponsibility.id", "AssetResponsibility.label", "AssetOwnership.asset", "AssetOwnership.organization", "AssetOwnership.period", "AssetOwnership.evidence", "AssetOperation.asset", "AssetOperation.organization", "AssetOperation.period", "AssetOperation.evidence", "AssetResponsibility.asset", "AssetResponsibility.organization", "AssetResponsibility.period", "AssetResponsibility.evidence" ], "affected_rules": [], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "Asset", "AssetOwnership", "AssetOperation", "AssetResponsibility" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "AssetOwnership.id", "AssetOwnership.label", "AssetOperation.id", "AssetOperation.label", "AssetResponsibility.id", "AssetResponsibility.label", "AssetOwnership.asset", "AssetOwnership.organization", "AssetOwnership.period", "AssetOwnership.evidence", "AssetOperation.asset", "AssetOperation.organization", "AssetOperation.period", "AssetOperation.evidence", "AssetResponsibility.asset", "AssetResponsibility.organization", "AssetResponsibility.period", "AssetResponsibility.evidence" ], "accepted_rules": [], "added_concepts": [ "AssetOwnership", "AssetOperation", "AssetResponsibility" ], "added_relationships": [ "AssetOwnership.id", "AssetOwnership.label", "AssetOperation.id", "AssetOperation.label", "AssetResponsibility.id", "AssetResponsibility.label", "AssetOwnership.asset", "AssetOwnership.organization", "AssetOwnership.period", "AssetOwnership.evidence", "AssetOperation.asset", "AssetOperation.organization", "AssetOperation.period", "AssetOperation.evidence", "AssetResponsibility.asset", "AssetResponsibility.organization", "AssetResponsibility.period", "AssetResponsibility.evidence" ], "deferred": [] }, "notes": [], "resolution_kind": "adopted" }, { "id": "Q005", "status": "accepted", "title": "発電所と号機", "question": "発電所の下に号機を置く階層とするか。", "rationale": "第2回の10問一括対話で確認。", "answer": "発電所の下に号機を置き、本オントロジーでの発電設備の最小粒度は号機とする。部品や装置までは分解しない。", "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "source_ids": [ "hokuden-retirement-plan" ], "affected_concepts": [ "PowerPlant", "GeneratingUnit" ], "affected_relationships": [ "PowerPlant.id", "PowerPlant.label", "GeneratingUnit.id", "GeneratingUnit.label", "GeneratingUnit.power_plant" ], "affected_rules": [], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "PowerPlant", "GeneratingUnit" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "PowerPlant.id", "PowerPlant.label", "GeneratingUnit.id", "GeneratingUnit.label", "GeneratingUnit.power_plant" ], "accepted_rules": [], "added_concepts": [ "PowerPlant", "GeneratingUnit" ], "added_relationships": [ "PowerPlant.id", "PowerPlant.label", "GeneratingUnit.id", "GeneratingUnit.label", "GeneratingUnit.power_plant" ], "deferred": [] }, "notes": [], "resolution_kind": "adopted" }, { "id": "Q006", "status": "accepted", "title": "事業ごとの対象範囲", "question": "役割の適用範囲をどう構成するか。", "rationale": "第2回の10問一括対話で確認。", "answer": "発電は発電所、送配電は地域、小売は地域と電圧種別の組合せを基本の対象範囲とする。", "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "source_ids": [ "org", "enecho" ], "affected_concepts": [ "Area", "Scope", "VoltageClass" ], "affected_relationships": [ "VoltageClass.id", "VoltageClass.label", "Scope.power_plant", "Scope.voltage_class", "Scope.area", "BusinessRole.code", "VoltageClass.code" ], "affected_rules": [ "R006" ], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "Area", "Scope", "VoltageClass" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "VoltageClass.id", "VoltageClass.label", "Scope.power_plant", "Scope.voltage_class", "Scope.area", "BusinessRole.code", "VoltageClass.code" ], "accepted_rules": [ "R006" ], "added_concepts": [ "VoltageClass" ], "added_relationships": [ "VoltageClass.id", "VoltageClass.label", "Scope.power_plant", "Scope.voltage_class", "BusinessRole.code", "VoltageClass.code" ], "deferred": [] }, "notes": [], "resolution_kind": "adopted" }, { "id": "Q007", "status": "accepted", "title": "実施日と予定", "question": "過去の事業承継の日付と予定をどう扱うか。", "rationale": "第2回の10問一括対話で確認。", "answer": "過去の承継は実際の承継日を基本とし、公表日や過去の予定日は必須にしない。予定は実施済みと区別して記録する。", "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "source_ids": [ "chuden-split", "hokuden-retirement-plan" ], "affected_concepts": [ "RoleTransition" ], "affected_relationships": [ "RoleTransition.id", "RoleTransition.label", "RoleTransition.kind", "RoleTransition.stage", "RoleTransition.actual_date", "RoleTransition.planned_date", "RoleTransition.evidence", "RoleTransition.from_assignment", "RoleTransition.to_assignment" ], "affected_rules": [ "R008" ], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "RoleTransition" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "RoleTransition.id", "RoleTransition.label", "RoleTransition.kind", "RoleTransition.stage", "RoleTransition.actual_date", "RoleTransition.planned_date", "RoleTransition.evidence", "RoleTransition.from_assignment", "RoleTransition.to_assignment" ], "accepted_rules": [ "R008" ], "added_concepts": [ "RoleTransition" ], "added_relationships": [ "RoleTransition.id", "RoleTransition.label", "RoleTransition.kind", "RoleTransition.stage", "RoleTransition.actual_date", "RoleTransition.planned_date", "RoleTransition.evidence", "RoleTransition.from_assignment", "RoleTransition.to_assignment" ], "deferred": [] }, "notes": [], "resolution_kind": "adopted" }, { "id": "Q008", "status": "accepted", "title": "価値と取引条件", "question": "価値と市場商品・契約の取引条件を分けるか。", "rationale": "第2回の10問一括対話で確認。", "answer": "電力量（kWh価値）、供給力（kW価値）、調整力（ΔkW価値）、環境価値を区別する。商品・契約は対象の価値と取引条件を別に持つ。", "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "source_ids": [ "jepx", "occto", "eprx-value", "jepx-environment" ], "affected_concepts": [ "ValueKind", "Product", "Contract" ], "affected_relationships": [ "ValueKind.code", "Product.value_kind", "Product.period", "Product.area", "Contract.party", "Contract.period", "Product.terms", "Contract.value_kind", "Contract.product", "Contract.terms" ], "affected_rules": [], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "ValueKind", "Product", "Contract" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "ValueKind.code", "Product.value_kind", "Product.period", "Product.area", "Contract.party", "Contract.period", "Product.terms", "Contract.value_kind", "Contract.product", "Contract.terms" ], "accepted_rules": [], "added_concepts": [], "added_relationships": [ "ValueKind.code", "Product.terms", "Contract.value_kind", "Contract.product", "Contract.terms" ], "deferred": [ "価値の呼称は単位変換規則ではない。調整力の確保と実際の調整電力量も混同しない。" ] }, "notes": [ "価値の呼称は単位変換規則ではない。調整力の確保と実際の調整電力量も混同しない。" ], "resolution_kind": "adopted" }, { "id": "Q009", "status": "accepted", "title": "指標と数値・版", "question": "指標定義、値、予測・実績、速報・確報、訂正前後を分けるか。", "rationale": "第2回の10問一括対話で確認。", "answer": "指標定義と個々の値を分離する。値に単位・対象期間・対象範囲・出典を持たせ、予測／実績と速報／確報を別軸にし、訂正前後を保存する。", "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "source_ids": [ "prov", "si" ], "affected_concepts": [ "Metric", "Observation", "Unit" ], "affected_relationships": [ "Observation.metric", "Observation.value", "Observation.unit", "Observation.period", "Observation.scope", "Observation.evidence", "Metric.unit", "Metric.formula", "Observation.value_nature", "Observation.publication_status", "Observation.revision_id", "Observation.revises" ], "affected_rules": [ "R003" ], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "Metric", "Observation", "Unit" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "Observation.metric", "Observation.value", "Observation.unit", "Observation.period", "Observation.scope", "Observation.evidence", "Metric.unit", "Metric.formula", "Observation.value_nature", "Observation.publication_status", "Observation.revision_id", "Observation.revises" ], "accepted_rules": [ "R003" ], "added_concepts": [], "added_relationships": [ "Observation.value_nature", "Observation.publication_status", "Observation.revision_id", "Observation.revises" ], "deferred": [] }, "notes": [], "resolution_kind": "adopted" }, { "id": "Q010", "status": "accepted", "title": "役割と制度上の資格の対応", "question": "役割と制度上の資格から相互に推定してよいか。", "rationale": "第2回の10問一括対話で確認。", "answer": "役割と資格は通常対応し、片方から他方を推定してよいという方針を採用する。ただし資格がなくても実質的な役割を担う例外を許容する。", "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "source_ids": [ "generation-notification", "generation-definition", "jepx-membership" ], "affected_concepts": [ "Qualification", "QualificationHolding" ], "affected_relationships": [ "Qualification.id", "Qualification.label", "QualificationHolding.id", "QualificationHolding.label", "Qualification.kind", "Qualification.conditions", "Qualification.policy", "QualificationHolding.organization", "QualificationHolding.qualification", "QualificationHolding.period", "QualificationHolding.scope", "QualificationHolding.assertion" ], "affected_rules": [ "R005" ], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "Qualification", "QualificationHolding" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "Qualification.id", "Qualification.label", "QualificationHolding.id", "QualificationHolding.label", "Qualification.kind", "Qualification.conditions", "Qualification.policy", "QualificationHolding.organization", "QualificationHolding.qualification", "QualificationHolding.period", "QualificationHolding.scope", "QualificationHolding.assertion" ], "accepted_rules": [ "R005" ], "added_concepts": [ "Qualification", "QualificationHolding" ], "added_relationships": [ "Qualification.id", "Qualification.label", "QualificationHolding.id", "QualificationHolding.label", "Qualification.kind", "Qualification.conditions", "Qualification.policy", "QualificationHolding.organization", "QualificationHolding.qualification", "QualificationHolding.period", "QualificationHolding.scope", "QualificationHolding.assertion" ], "deferred": [ "無条件の同一クラス・双方向同値にはしない。方向・期間・範囲・定義と要件の対応を個別ルールで確認した場合は確定推論、未確認条件があれば仮定つき推定として記録する。現時点で実制度に対する確定推論用の対応表は未登録。" ] }, "notes": [ "無条件の同一クラス・双方向同値にはしない。方向・期間・範囲・定義と要件の対応を個別ルールで確認した場合は確定推論、未確認条件があれば仮定つき推定として記録する。現時点で実制度に対する確定推論用の対応表は未登録。" ], "resolution_kind": "conditional" }, { "id": "Q011", "status": "accepted", "title": "事実・推論・示唆と不明", "question": "記録なしを不明とし、論理的な推論と仮定つき示唆を認めるか。", "rationale": "第2回の10問一括対話で確認。", "answer": "記録がないことは不明とする。確認した事実、事実とルールから論理的に導いた結果、仮定を明示した断定的でない示唆を区別して利用する。", "answered_at": "2026-09-28", "source_ids": [ "prov", "ossie" ], "affected_concepts": [ "Evidence", "KnowledgeAssertion" ], "affected_relationships": [ "KnowledgeAssertion.id", "KnowledgeAssertion.label", "RoleAssignment.assertion", "KnowledgeAssertion.statement_text", "KnowledgeAssertion.epistemic_status", "KnowledgeAssertion.evidence", "KnowledgeAssertion.premise", "KnowledgeAssertion.rule_id", "KnowledgeAssertion.assumption", "KnowledgeAssertion.scope", "KnowledgeAssertion.period" ], "affected_rules": [ "R007" ], "delta": { "accepted_concepts": [ "Evidence", "KnowledgeAssertion" ], "accepted_relationships": [ "KnowledgeAssertion.id", "KnowledgeAssertion.label", "RoleAssignment.assertion", "KnowledgeAssertion.statement_text", "KnowledgeAssertion.epistemic_status", "KnowledgeAssertion.evidence", "KnowledgeAssertion.premise", "KnowledgeAssertion.rule_id", "KnowledgeAssertion.assumption", "KnowledgeAssertion.scope", "KnowledgeAssertion.period" ], "accepted_rules": [ "R007" ], "added_concepts": [ "KnowledgeAssertion" ], "added_relationships": [ "KnowledgeAssertion.id", "KnowledgeAssertion.label", "RoleAssignment.assertion", "KnowledgeAssertion.statement_text", "KnowledgeAssertion.epistemic_status", "KnowledgeAssertion.evidence", "KnowledgeAssertion.premise", "KnowledgeAssertion.rule_id", "KnowledgeAssertion.assumption", "KnowledgeAssertion.scope", "KnowledgeAssertion.period" ], "deferred": [ "仮定つき示唆を観測事実へ昇格させない。確定推論でも適用した規則と前提を追跡できるようにする。" ] }, "notes": [ "仮定つき示唆を観測事実へ昇格させない。確定推論でも適用した規則と前提を追跡できるようにする。" ], "resolution_kind": "adopted" }, { "id": "Q012", "status": "awaiting_answer", "title": "発電者という役割の範囲", "question": "「発電者」は設備所有者を指す役割と、設備を運用して発電事業を担う役割に分けますか。保有外の設備で発電を継続できる場合は、全保有設備の廃止だけでは後者を終了させない整理を提案します。", "rationale": "次回の10問一括対話。未回答を同意とは扱わない。", "answer": null, "source_ids": [], "affected_concepts": [ "Organization", "BusinessRole", "AssetOwnership", "AssetResponsibility" ], "affected_relationships": [], "delta": null }, { "id": "Q013", "status": "awaiting_answer", "title": "役割・資格の推定の扱い", "question": "対応条件を一次資料で確認できた場合は確定推論、それ以外は「資格保有の可能性」等の仮定つき推定として表示する、という実装でよいですか。", "rationale": "次回の10問一括対話。未回答を同意とは扱わない。", "answer": null, "source_ids": [], "affected_concepts": [ "Qualification", "QualificationHolding", "KnowledgeAssertion" ], "affected_relationships": [], "delta": null }, { "id": "Q014", "status": "awaiting_answer", "title": "企業間関係の種類", "question": "法人間関係はまず親子会社・出資・事業承継の3種類を扱う方針でよいですか。優先したい別の関係があれば教えてください。", "rationale": "次回の10問一括対話。未回答を同意とは扱わない。", "answer": null, "source_ids": [], "affected_concepts": [ "OrganizationRelation" ], "affected_relationships": [], "delta": null }, { "id": "Q015", "status": "awaiting_answer", "title": "発電所・号機の同一性", "question": "名称変更や号機番号の変更は同じIDの履歴とし、設備の全面的な更新・建替えは別の号機IDとして前後をつなぐ整理でよいですか。", "rationale": "次回の10問一括対話。未回答を同意とは扱わない。", "answer": null, "source_ids": [], "affected_concepts": [ "PowerPlant", "GeneratingUnit" ], "affected_relationships": [], "delta": null }, { "id": "Q016", "status": "awaiting_answer", "title": "号機の内訳が分からない場合", "question": "資料が発電所単位だけの場合は、その粒度で記録し、実在を確認できない仮の号機を作らない整理でよいですか。", "rationale": "次回の10問一括対話。未回答を同意とは扱わない。", "answer": null, "source_ids": [], "affected_concepts": [ "PowerPlant", "GeneratingUnit", "Observation" ], "affected_relationships": [], "delta": null }, { "id": "Q017", "status": "awaiting_answer", "title": "地域の基本単位", "question": "送配電・小売の地域は一般送配電事業者の供給エリアを基本にし、都道府県等は別の地域体系として対応表でつなぐ整理でよいですか。", "rationale": "次回の10問一括対話。未回答を同意とは扱わない。", "answer": null, "source_ids": [], "affected_concepts": [ "Area", "Scope" ], "affected_relationships": [], "delta": null }, { "id": "Q018", "status": "awaiting_answer", "title": "終了日が分からない役割", "question": "終了日がない記録は「継続中と確認済み」と「終了時点が不明」を分け、単に空欄という理由だけで現在も継続中と判断しない整理でよいですか。", "rationale": "次回の10問一括対話。未回答を同意とは扱わない。", "answer": null, "source_ids": [], "affected_concepts": [ "Period", "RoleAssignment" ], "affected_relationships": [], "delta": null }, { "id": "Q019", "status": "awaiting_answer", "title": "資料間の不一致", "question": "同じ対象・時点で資料が食い違う場合は両方を残し、発行主体・原資料・訂正関係を見て採用値を別途決める整理でよいですか。", "rationale": "次回の10問一括対話。未回答を同意とは扱わない。", "answer": null, "source_ids": [], "affected_concepts": [ "Evidence", "Observation", "KnowledgeAssertion" ], "affected_relationships": [], "delta": null }, { "id": "Q020", "status": "awaiting_answer", "title": "取引条件の構造化", "question": "商品・契約の条件は、受渡期間、対象地域、数量・単位、価格、提供義務・未達時の扱いを優先して構造化する方針でよいですか。", "rationale": "次回の10問一括対話。未回答を同意とは扱わない。", "answer": null, "source_ids": [], "affected_concepts": [ "Product", "Contract", "ValueKind" ], "affected_relationships": [], "delta": null }, { "id": "Q021", "status": "awaiting_answer", "title": "共通知識の再利用条件", "question": "独自に整理したオントロジーは、出典表示を条件とするCC BY 4.0と、条件を極力なくすCC0のどちらを基本にしますか。第三者の資料そのものは対象に含めません。", "rationale": "次回の10問一括対話。未回答を同意とは扱わない。", "answer": null, "source_ids": [], "affected_concepts": [ "Evidence" ], "affected_relationships": [], "delta": null } ], "releases": [ { "version": "0.1.0-draft", "date": "2026-09-28", "reason": "既存のデータ収集・分析の論点から共通の型を抽出。初回対話の回答待ち。", "added_concepts": [ "Organization", "BusinessRole", "RoleAssignment", "Scope", "Area", "Period", "Asset", "DemandPoint", "Market", "Product", "ValueKind", "Contract", "Tariff", "Policy", "Metric", "Observation", "Unit", "Dataset", "Evidence", "FinancialBoundary", "Identifier", "Label", "NumericValue", "Timestamp", "Text" ], "added_relationships": [ "Organization.id", "Organization.label", "BusinessRole.id", "BusinessRole.label", "RoleAssignment.id", "RoleAssignment.label", "Scope.id", "Scope.label", "Area.id", "Area.label", "Period.id", "Period.label", "Asset.id", "Asset.label", "DemandPoint.id", "DemandPoint.label", "Market.id", "Market.label", "Product.id", "Product.label", "ValueKind.id", "ValueKind.label", "Contract.id", "Contract.label", "Tariff.id", "Tariff.label", "Policy.id", "Policy.label", "Metric.id", "Metric.label", "Observation.id", "Observation.label", "Unit.id", "Unit.label", "Dataset.id", "Dataset.label", "Evidence.id", "Evidence.label", "FinancialBoundary.id", "FinancialBoundary.label", "RoleAssignment.organization", "RoleAssignment.role", "RoleAssignment.period", "RoleAssignment.scope", "RoleAssignment.evidence", "Scope.area", "Period.start", "Period.end", "Asset.operator", "Asset.owner", "Asset.area", "DemandPoint.area", "Market.operator", "Market.product", "Product.value_kind", "Product.period", "Product.area", "Contract.party", "Contract.period", "Contract.tariff", "Tariff.policy", "Policy.period", "Policy.stage", "Observation.metric", "Observation.value", "Observation.unit", "Observation.period", "Observation.scope", "Observation.evidence", "Observation.value_status", "Metric.unit", "Metric.formula", "Dataset.observation", "Evidence.url", "Evidence.checked_at", "Observation.standard_unit" ], "changed": [], "deprecated": [], "accepted_answers": 0 }, { "version": "0.2.0-draft", "date": "2026-09-28", "reason": "Q001の回答を反映。法人と期間・範囲つき役割割当を最初の合意として採用。別法人への移転を架空例で可視化し、設備の変化と役割終了の関係を次の論点へ。", "added_concepts": [], "added_relationships": [], "changed": [ "Organization", "BusinessRole", "RoleAssignment", "Scope", "Period", "RoleAssignment.organization", "RoleAssignment.role", "RoleAssignment.period", "RoleAssignment.scope" ], "deprecated": [], "accepted_answers": 1 }, { "version": "0.3.0-draft", "date": "2026-09-28", "reason": "Q002〜Q011の10回答を一括反映。設備と法人の関係・事業別範囲・4つの価値・数値の版・事実と推論を整備。2論点の自動推論は条件と仮定を明示する。", "added_concepts": [ "CorporateGroup", "GroupMembership", "OrganizationRelation", "PowerPlant", "GeneratingUnit", "AssetOwnership", "AssetOperation", "AssetResponsibility", "VoltageClass", "AssetEvent", "RoleTransition", "Qualification", "QualificationHolding", "KnowledgeAssertion" ], "added_relationships": [ "CorporateGroup.id", "CorporateGroup.label", "GroupMembership.id", "GroupMembership.label", "OrganizationRelation.id", "OrganizationRelation.label", "PowerPlant.id", "PowerPlant.label", "GeneratingUnit.id", "GeneratingUnit.label", "AssetOwnership.id", "AssetOwnership.label", "AssetOperation.id", "AssetOperation.label", "AssetResponsibility.id", "AssetResponsibility.label", "VoltageClass.id", "VoltageClass.label", "AssetEvent.id", "AssetEvent.label", "RoleTransition.id", "RoleTransition.label", "Qualification.id", "Qualification.label", "QualificationHolding.id", "QualificationHolding.label", "KnowledgeAssertion.id", "KnowledgeAssertion.label", "AssetOwnership.asset", "AssetOwnership.organization", "AssetOwnership.period", "AssetOwnership.evidence", "AssetOperation.asset", "AssetOperation.organization", "AssetOperation.period", "AssetOperation.evidence", "AssetResponsibility.asset", "AssetResponsibility.organization", "AssetResponsibility.period", "AssetResponsibility.evidence", "GroupMembership.group", "GroupMembership.organization", "GroupMembership.period", "GroupMembership.evidence", "OrganizationRelation.source_organization", "OrganizationRelation.target_organization", "OrganizationRelation.kind", "OrganizationRelation.period", "OrganizationRelation.evidence", "FinancialBoundary.organization", "FinancialBoundary.period", "GeneratingUnit.power_plant", "Scope.power_plant", "Scope.voltage_class", "BusinessRole.code", "ValueKind.code", "VoltageClass.code", "AssetEvent.kind", "AssetEvent.stage", "AssetEvent.actual_date", "AssetEvent.planned_date", "AssetEvent.evidence", "RoleTransition.kind", "RoleTransition.stage", "RoleTransition.actual_date", "RoleTransition.planned_date", "RoleTransition.evidence", "AssetEvent.asset", "RoleTransition.from_assignment", "RoleTransition.to_assignment", "Product.terms", "Contract.value_kind", "Contract.product", "Contract.terms", "Observation.value_nature", "Observation.publication_status", "Observation.revision_id", "Observation.revises", "Qualification.kind", "Qualification.conditions", "Qualification.policy", "QualificationHolding.organization", "QualificationHolding.qualification", "QualificationHolding.period", "QualificationHolding.scope", "QualificationHolding.assertion", "RoleAssignment.assertion", "KnowledgeAssertion.statement_text", "KnowledgeAssertion.epistemic_status", "KnowledgeAssertion.evidence", "KnowledgeAssertion.premise", "KnowledgeAssertion.rule_id", "KnowledgeAssertion.assumption", "KnowledgeAssertion.scope", "KnowledgeAssertion.period" ], "changed": [ "Scope", "Area", "Asset", "Product", "ValueKind", "Contract", "Metric", "Observation", "Unit", "Evidence", "FinancialBoundary", "Scope.area", "Asset.operator", "Asset.owner", "Product.value_kind", "Product.period", "Product.area", "Contract.party", "Contract.period", "Observation.metric", "Observation.value", "Observation.unit", "Observation.period", "Observation.scope", "Observation.evidence", "Observation.value_status", "Metric.unit", "Metric.formula" ], "deprecated": [], "accepted_answers": 11 } ], "roadmap": [ "主体と役割", "価値・物理量・商品", "時間・地域・集計範囲", "観測値・予測・算定値", "契約・制度の状態", "行動・推論の境界", "再利用ライセンス" ], "current_stage": "行動・推論の境界", "batch_size": 10, "current_questions": [ "Q012", "Q013", "Q014", "Q015", "Q016", "Q017", "Q018", "Q019", "Q020", "Q021" ] }